Wealth, Virtual Wealth and Debt

Wealth, Virtual Wealth and Debt: The Solution of the Economic Paradox by Frederick Soddy (1933)

Frederick Soddy was a noted scientist of the early 20th century who won a Nobel Prize in 1921 for developing radioisotopes. By 1933, he was well aware, with Einstein and others, of the potential in nuclear energy. But after 1921, Soddy turned to the mysteries of economics. This work is his summing up, written in charming Victorian English.

Soddy has been panned because he identified with a popular 1920s global conspiracy theory that Jewish bankers were plotting to rule the world, but in writing he denounces all bankers for “virtual wealth” — excess interest and profits – predatory capitalism. The prejudice showing in the book is that non-Whites are never scientists. Set aside that bias of his time, and he offers cogent arguments.

Insights scattered throughout are still relevant today: The public is deluded by the “preposterous humbug” of the monetary system. That system should distribute wealth, not concentrate it. Real capital abstains from present consumption to produce something in the future; anything else is not real capital. An “iron law” rules a society faced with scarcity: in the absence of social justice, somebody loses.

The rich rig the money system to benefit them. To rectify this, Soddy proposed a “learned jury” of commoners to decide: modify, simplify, or scrap. This jury would have to cut through economists’ mystifying word spinning and equation fogging.

Any such jury would surely squelch the ability of private parties, like banks, to create and destroy money. Soddy discovered that many bank loans are simply loan accounts set up as assets to the bank, creating money out of thin air. Few people still realize this. Today it’s called fractional reserve lending. Public banks are a proposed solution. Why should we pay interest on thin air to private parties? Why not pay it to ourselves?

Public banks being in the future, Soddy excoriated private banks for creating money, asserting that only a “national mint” should issue money. Long before credit cards and the explosion of consumer credit, Soddy wanted financial institutions to boost the economy by issuing more consumer credit. Now we may have overdone consumer credit, but even in his time Soddy decried the system as a few gaining wealth by debt peonage of the poor – lifetimes of economic thralldom in hopeless debt.

Soddy was taken with the thought that capital spent in hopes of future gain should have limited life. After all, machines wear out. Income from an innovator’s wondrous thing should not be patent protected forever. Why should an idle class live on the exploits of their grandparents? Is that not akin to the rentier status of feudal lords? (The remnants of feudal society were within Soddy’s life experience.)

Unique among philosophical economists, Soddy realized that the formulas of market capitalism were unrealistic. Financial growth formulas can grow to infinity. The laws of matter and energy can’t, so finance creates the illusion of perpetual motion. Sooner or later the physics of nature must dispel this illusion. Then this system must give way to something more realistic, but it won’t be easy. “We cling to the illusions of class societies, and mad uprush into the possessing classes without recognizing that our existence is parasitic on nature.”

To get real, Soddy proposed an economy based on energy. All economic activity requires energy: human energy, animal energy, plant energy, and fuel energy; all originating from the thermonuclear energy of the sun, but he could not figure out how to base an effective monetary system on constants of energy. Below is his energy-fueled economy:

Of WWI, Soddy observed that while the battlefields were atrocious, Britain’s domestic economy boomed. When it was over, gushers of cash drained away. “We have returned to peace and squalor.” Nothing seems to motivate intense, focused economic activity like a war. Perhaps the only good that came from WWI was that the vestiges of the royal-feudal system were laid to rest in “the stricken fields of Flanders.”

Soddy had mixed feelings about atomic energy. He could envision it catalyzing the “potentialities of a civilization such as the world has not yet imagined possible.” On the other hand, he feared that we would apply atomic energy first to the arts of war, which he lived to see us do. Our problems are within us, not our technologies.

Throughout the book, Soddy poses enduring moral questions about any economic system. Does it presume that men live to work, or only work to live? How do we overcome the abuse that passes for argument? Of the present system, can anyone contemplate a coming millennium in which everyone lives off the interest of our own mutual indebtedness? A good question is whether “an enlarged reproduction” of any system would satisfy any soul.


Wealth, Virtual Wealth and Debt by Frederick Soddy can be downloaded in various formats from: http://www.fadedpage.com/showbook.php?pid=20140873

Fractional reserve lending: https://quickonomics.com/fractional-reserve-banking/

Public Banking: http://www.publicbankinginstitute.org/

Corollary Book: The Role of Money, (1934): https://archive.org/details/roleofmoney032861mbp

Evonomics and “economism” – belief that simple economic models can explain all and resolve all problems, that the government solution is always bad: http://evonomics.com/ideologues-economics-minimum-wage-kwak/

Alexa everywhere, in everything: https://www.wired.com/story/amazon-alexa-development-kit/

Understanding the Intangible Economy: https://hackernoon.com/the-value-of-economic-classification-systems-99b00a01f179

Recent Posts:

The Influence of Neoliberalism Runs Deep

The Influence of Neoliberalism Runs Deep Better known in the United States as Libertarianism, neoliberal dogma began as simplistic assumptions in old quantitative economic models, before computers; later economists were not as constrained. Moneyed people glommed onto...

“Deep” Complexity

A graphic depiction of Gaia from Pixabay, showing that we are connected to each other, to our ecology, and to everything else. That everything in the entire universe, not just earth bound systems, all somehow link together.   Can We Understand Complexity or Only...

Covid-19 Complexity

This is one variation of Ouroboros, a snake eating its own tail -- doesn't recognize its own tail.. Here Ouroboros is also shown in the form of the universal symbol for infinity, signifying deep, hidden feedback connections that we might never be able to fathom with...

A Microbiomic Crisis

The Economy Critically Disrupts the Balance of Nature  Black Lives Matter demonstrations all over the world crowded Covid-19 out of the news, swelling into a pandemic of demonstrations in small towns as well as big cities on six continents. Triggered by the death of...

Planet of the Humans

Planet of the Humans, movie by Michael Moore and Jeff Gibbs Moore and Gibbs’ movie appears calculated to incite controversy. If so, they certainly roiled the environmental community. So far, it’s received little mainstream attention, and a few environmental activists...

Finding Our Real Reserves

Finding Our Real Reserves April 7, 2020  Covid-19 and its economic tailspin presage many more crises to come. We must change how we live and how we think. Our economic objectives have set us up for Covid-19, with more debacles on the way. What we have assumed to...

System Fragility

Above: Model of the Corona Virus. At Right: Diagram of our proper priorities: Earth first; us second; profit third. Or, should profit be no more than a systemic convention? Collapse Now and Avoid the Rush First in a Series “Collapse Now and Avoid the Rush” is a stock...

Legal Creep

  Legal Creep Or why we think there is no alternative to economic expansion A better sub-title for this essay with two book reviews might be “can we escape our self-deception that economic expansion is necessary?” Whether economic expansion is labeled capitalist...

Follow Us: